A Nation of Settlers, Not Immigrants
On a recent appearance on “The Will Cain Show,” Fox News personality Rachel Campos-Duffy made a strong statement challenging the common narrative that America is a “nation of immigrants.” Instead, she argued that the United States was built by “settlers,” individuals who came to the land and created a new identity and culture. This perspective directly contrasts with the traditional view often promoted by progressive voices, which emphasizes the role of immigration in shaping the nation.
Campos-Duffy questioned why the left continues to support undocumented immigrants over American citizens who have been negatively impacted by open-border policies. She suggested that the debate is not just about immigration but about the very identity of the country. “Are we a nation of immigrants, or are we a nation of settlers?” she asked. According to her, the latter is more accurate, as the country was formed by those who settled and established a new society, allowing immigrants to assimilate afterward.
This argument comes at a time when President Donald Trump has intensified his deportation efforts. The administration has focused on removing undocumented immigrants, many of whom do not have criminal records. Data from Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) shows a significant increase in arrests of migrants without prior convictions. Since Trump took office, these arrests have risen by 807%, with 65% of all deported individuals having no criminal history.
These raids, often targeting workplaces such as farms, have sparked backlash from Democrats and activists. Some have even attempted to interfere with ICE operations, leading to heightened tensions between the government and those opposing the policies. However, Campos-Duffy claims that the opposition is not driven by concerns about due process or the violent nature of the raids. Instead, she suggests that critics of the policy are motivated by a deeper disdain for America itself.
“They hate America; they hate our founding story, they hate our founding fathers, they hate everything about us, our founding documents, they hate it,” she said. According to her, the presence of undocumented immigrants represents an opportunity for the left to reshape the country into what she describes as a “Marxist, dystopian perfect utopia.”
Cain, the host of the show, expressed approval of Campos-Duffy’s comments, noting that similar discussions take place in his own home after watching “Fox and Friends,” where she serves as a co-host. “Now that is good stuff!” he said. “That is the type of stuff that you got on the couch in my office after ‘Fox and Friends,’ and I’m so happy that I got it here today on ‘The Will Cain show.'”
Impact of Deportation Policies
The increased focus on deportations has led to a broader conversation about the effectiveness and fairness of current immigration enforcement. Critics argue that the policies may be counterproductive, as they could deter legal immigrants from coming to the U.S. or discourage workers from seeking employment in certain sectors. Additionally, some experts have raised concerns about how these policies might affect the economy and labor market.
Despite the controversy, supporters of the policies argue that they are necessary to protect national security and uphold the rule of law. They emphasize the need to address the challenges posed by illegal immigration, including the strain on public resources and the potential risks associated with uncontrolled border crossings.
As the debate continues, the discussion around what it means to be an American remains central. Whether one views the country as a “nation of immigrants” or a “nation of settlers” reflects deeper ideological divides. These perspectives shape not only how people understand the past but also how they envision the future of the United States.
